M. Bowles et al., RECOVERY PLANNING AND REINTRODUCTION OF THE FEDERALLY THREATENED PITCHERS THISTLE (CIRSIUM PITCHERI) IN ILLINOIS, Natural areas journal, 13(3), 1993, pp. 164-176
Pitcher's thistle (Cirsium pitcheri) is a narrowly distributed endemic
of the western Great Lakes shorelines. This monocarpic herb is an obl
igate colonizer of >70% open sand habitat in early- to mid-successiona
l vegetation maintained by intermediate levels of disturbance or creat
ed by stochastic disturbance events. Its persistence can be modeled wi
thin a metapopulation framework, where interacting populations react t
o environmental factors independently, facilitating metapopulation per
sistence. The habitat requirements of Pitcher's thistle have made it e
xtremely vulnerable to shoreline erosion, development, and recreationa
l use. It is federally listed as threatened and state listed as endang
ered or threatened throughout its range in the United States. In Illin
ois, Pitcher's thistle was collected at least twelve times from the La
ke Michigan shoreline between 1862 and 1919; it then apparently disapp
eared, probably as a result of the combined effects of increasing huma
n activity, lake level fluctuations, collecting, and other chance even
ts. Restoration of Cirsium pitcheri in Illinois is an objective of the
federal recovery plan, and Illinois Beach State Park contains the onl
y remaining Illinois dune systems where it might be reintroduced. To i
dentify appropriate restoration habitat, the vegetation at Illinois Be
ach was compared to the nearest occupied Cirsium pitcheri habitats, at
Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore and at Kohler-Andrae State Park in W
isconsin. Ordination and cluster analysis demonstrated strong similari
ties between upper beach, foredune, secondary dune, and dunefield habi
tat in Illinois and similar thistle-occupied habitats in Indiana and W
isconsin. However, at Illinois Beach State Park only the secondary dun
e habitat appeared to be free from shoreline erosion and recreational
impacts. Propagated plants from Indiana and Wisconsin seed sources wer
e introduced into this habitat in 1991, with greater survivorship amon
g the Indiana plants. Experimental establishment of additional cohorts
from seeds and propagated material is needed to further identify appr
opriate microhabitat, while shoreline protection, control of recreatio
n, and periodic reintroduction may be required to maintain a metapopul
ation at Illinois Beach.