E. Mcauley et S. Shaffer, AFFECTIVE RESPONSES TO EXTERNALLY AND PERSONALLY CONTROLLABLE ATTRIBUTIONS, Basic and applied social psychology, 14(4), 1993, pp. 475-485
The purpose of this study was to examine the relations between the ext
ernal control and personal control dimensions of the revised Causal Di
mension Scale (CDSII; McAuley, Duncan, & Russell, 1992) and affective
responses to a negative event. Employing a scenario methodology, subje
cts (N = 100) were asked to make attributions for and record intensity
of affective responses to a negative event that was personally uncont
rollable and externally controllable. We hypothesized that externally
controllable attributions should be implicated in the generation of af
fective responses such as anger, whereas self-related (i.e., personall
y controllable) attributions would be more strongly related to guilt-r
elated affects. Correlational and hierarchical multiple-regression ana
lyses supported the hypotheses. Moreover, the correlation between the
external control and personal control dimensions was only moderate (r
= .44). This contrasts with other studies that have shown these dimens
ions to be very highly related and distinct, perhaps only at the conce
ptual level. The results are discussed with respect to the role played
by both control dimensions in the generation of affective responses a
nd the clear distinction between the two dimensions in situations that
truly are externally controlled.