Re. Barrick et al., PALEOTEMPERATURES VERSUS SEA-LEVEL - OXYGEN-ISOTOPE SIGNAL FROM FISH BONE PHOSPHATE OF THE MIOCENE CALVERT CLIFFS, MARYLAND, Paleoceanography, 8(6), 1993, pp. 845-858
The use of skeletal oxygen isotopic records for use in paleotemperatur
e reconstruction has been hampered by the lack of independent evidence
for ocean water oxygen isotopic composition. The delta(18)O record fr
om homeothermic cetaceans has provided an independent estimate of ocea
n delta(18)O values represented by the Calvert and Choptank formations
of Maryland. Fish teeth and bones (especially shark and ray teeth) we
re also collected from these sediments and provide the basis for paleo
temperature estimates for represented time slices of the middle Miocen
e. Trends in delta(18)O values of the fish phosphate throughout the Ca
lvert Formation are of opposite polarity to the trends from the cetace
an bone phosphate. Paleotemperatures calculated using the cetacean pro
xies for ocean delta(18)O values sharpen the already present trend, in
dicating that ocean temperatures increased during episodes of greater
glaciation and decreased during periods of lesser or no glaciation. Wh
en using modern average ocean values of 0 parts per thousand SMOW in t
he paleotemperature calculation, however, corrected paleotemperatures
for the Choptank Formation do not alter the existing pattern of temper
atures