H. Kuhs, CATATONIC SYMPTOMS IN AFFECTIVE-DISORDERS - EXAMINATION OF DSM-IV CRITERIA FROM A PSYCHOPATHOLOGICAL STANDPOINT, Zeitschrift fur klinische Psychologie, Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie, 45(1), 1997, pp. 36-44
In the classification of mood disorders, symptomatological criteria ar
e stressed by DSM-IV. Taking the newly introduced criteria for cataton
ic features as an example, critical comment is made on the DSM-IV proc
edure from a psychopathological perspective. Some catatonic symptoms c
an only be delineated at will, while others are ignored. With operatio
nalized criteria, the use of complex psychopathological phenomena (e.g
. negativism) along with relatively easily comprehensible symptoms (e.
g, mutism) gives rise to special problems. Basically, the problem of w
hich psychomotor symptoms have to be regarded as catatonic has yet to
be clarified. The question also arises of whether the algorithm of the
DSM-IV is in accordance with the importance of the respective symptom
s in identifying a mood disorder as catatonic. The relationship betwee
n catatonic and other depressive symptoms, especially depressive mood,
is also discussed.