Rm. Burgess et al., SAND SPIKED WITH COPPER AS A REFERENCE TOXICANT MATERIAL FOR SEDIMENTTOXICITY TESTING - A PRELIMINARY EVALUATION, Archives of environmental contamination and toxicology, 26(2), 1994, pp. 163-168
Routine use of solid-phase sediment toxicity tests for scientific and
regulatory purposes necessitates the development of solid-phase refere
nce toxicant materials. In order to evaluate an approach for developin
g such materials, 12 solid-phase 96-h reference toxicant tests were co
nducted over 12 weeks with the marine bivalve Mulinia lateralis. Refer
ence toxicant material was clean muffled sand spiked with copper used
in a conventional dilution series with unspiked sand as the diluent. C
ontrol survival ranged from 92 to 100% and during the exposure weights
increased by a factor of about 3 relative to initial weights. Measure
d concentrations of copper in the water column above the reference mat
erial during testing showed that the toxicant exposures were relativel
y consistent between tests. Coefficients of variation (CV) for mortali
ty and sublethality (growth) endpoints were 39% and 42%, respectively.
Coefficients of variation for other solid-phase reference toxicant ma
terial studies do not exist, but comparison of the results of this stu
dy with water-only literature values are favorable. Values for CVs in
the literature range from 4 to 120% and 2 to 48% for acute and subleth
al endpoints, respectively, for water column organisms and about 45% f
or an acute test using the marine amphipod (Ampelisca abdita). This ev
aluation demonstrates that use of sand spiked with copper is a credibl
e approach for developing a solid phase reference toxicant material; h
owever, further development is required to reduce both biological and
chemical sources of variability.