The relation between immigration and the economic welfare of residents
is analyzed for resource-rich economies (such as Australia) both unde
r competitive conditions and when various distortions are present. Imm
igration provides efficiency gains for residents under distortion-free
competition for standard 'gains from trade' reasons. Such reasons, ho
wever, tend to be ignored by immigration and 'optimal population' theo
rists who raise the issue of restricting immigration without explicitl
y referring to the distortions. In situations where distortions and ex
ternalities are present we argue that it is generally preferable to de
vise policies which specifically target the distortions than to restri
ct immigration.