D. Andelman et H. Orland, CHIRAL DISCRIMINATION IN SOLUTIONS AND IN LANGMUIR MONOLAYERS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(26), 1993, pp. 12322-12329
In this paper we examine theoretically the chiral discrimination of mo
lecules with a single chiral center. We propose a definition of the ch
iral discrimination parameter DELTA in terms of the difference between
the second virial coefficient of pure enantiomers and their racemic m
ixture. This parameter enters in the equation of state of racemic mixt
ures and will determine their phase diagrams. We calculate then the ch
iral discrimination between D- and L-alanine using a Monte Carlo simul
ation to average over 11 molecular degrees of freedom at fixed intermo
lecular distances using the CHARMM energy function. The discrimination
is found to slightly favor homochirality and mainly comes from steric
hindrance at short distances. We also perform a direct integration fo
r rigid chiral tetrahedron-shaped molecules. Here there are only five
rotational degrees of freedom. For a Lennard-Jones potential, the over
all chiral discrimination is found to be predominantly heterochiral. O
ne of our main observations is that the pair free energy, internal ene
rgy, and entropy differences between the two enantiomers may change si
gns as a function of the interpair distance. We find that homochiralit
y is preferred at shorter distances whereas heterochirality is favored
at larger distances. With our model molecules a strong chiral discrim
ination of about 43% is found. The calculation is repeated for molecul
es that are restricted to lie at the water/air interface. Those model
molecules can be regarded as tripodal amphiphiles creating a chiral La
ngmuir monolayer at the water/air interface. Here the chiral discrimin
ation is found to be smaller (about 8.8%) but still significantly hete
rochiral.