J. Ramsell et al., WHEN GRAZED BY TIPULA-PALUDOSA, LOLIUM-PERENNE IS A STRONGER COMPETITOR OF RUMEX-OBTUSIFOLIUS, Journal of Ecology, 81(4), 1993, pp. 777-786
1 Experiments were conducted to investigate the effect of root-grazing
by Tipula paludosa on competitive interactions between Rumex obtusifo
lius and Lolium perenne in the glasshouse. 2 Preference tests found th
at T paludosa larvae preferred L. perenne to R. obtusifolius plant mat
erial, consuming twice as much of the former when presented with eithe
r the shoot material or the whole plant. 3 Competition experiments inv
olved replacement series at a range of planting densities and the meth
odology of Jolliffe et al. (1984). 4 Leatherjacket grazing significant
ly reduced L. perenne but not R. obtusifolius dry weights in monocultu
re in the glasshouse. 5 Reduced L. perenne total plant dry weights in
grazed monocultures consisted primarily of reduced amounts of root mat
erial, reflected in a lower L. perenne root: shoot ratio in the presen
ce of tipulids. 6 Intraspecific competition in R. obtusifolius monocul
tures was not significantly affected by tipulid grazing, but in L. per
enne monocultures, it was significantly greater in grazed than ungraze
d treatments. 7 Tipulid grazing significantly reduced L. perenne plant
dry weight in mixtures, while having no significant effect on R. obtu
sifolius dry weights. 8 Tipulid grazing of L. perenne reduced the impa
ct of interspecific competition from R. obtusifolius on L. perenne, im
plying that grazed L. perenne was a stronger competitor than ungrazed
L. perenne. 9 It appears that root grazing of the grass led to a relat
ive increase in the shoot production of L. perenne which together best
owed an increased competitive ability on grazed L. perenne when in com
petition with R. obtusifolius.