The x-ray structures of three esterase-like catalytic antibodies ident
ified by screening for catalytic activity the entire hybridoma reperto
ire, elicited in response to a phosphonate transition state analog (TS
A) hapten, were analyzed. The high resolution structures account for c
atalysis by transition state stabilization, and in all three antibodie
s a tyrosine residue participates in the oxyanion hole. Despite signif
icant conformational differences in their combining sites, the three a
ntibodies, which are the most efficient among those elicited, achieve
catalysis in essentially the same mode, suggesting that evolution for
binding to a single TSA followed by screening for catalysis lead to an
tibodies with structural convergence.