Abundances of organic carbon, sulfur, and reactive iron in sediments o
f three upwelling environments (Peru, Oman and Benguela) suggest that
organic carbon/reduced sulfur ratios (C/S-ratios) in this category of
marine sediments deviate considerably from previously established empi
rical ratios in normal marine sediments. To clarify the discrepancies,
we investigated those components of the diagenetic system that limit
the formation of pyrite: sulfate concentrations and reduction rates in
pore waters, availability of reactive iron, and the quantity and qual
ity of organic matter. All three limitations are evident in our sample
pools. The results suggest that C/S-ratios in recent and fossil marin
e sediments rich in organic matter may be unsuitable as paleoenvironme
ntal indicators.