R. Finlayjones et G. Parker, A CONSENSUS CONFERENCE ON PSYCHOTIC DEPRESSION, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 27(4), 1993, pp. 581-589
We report a consensus conference on psychotic depression that addresse
d historic, classification, phenomenologic, epidemiologic, aetiologic,
management and outcome issues. We were able to detail the impact of t
he information offered by having audience members complete questionnai
res before and after the conference. The respondents indicated that th
e status of psychotic depression (as a separate type or as a more seve
re expression of depression) remains unclear; that delusions, hallucin
ations and severe psychomotor disturbance have high cross-sectional di
agnostic weighting (while longitudinal information is of importance);
that determinants include both genetic and organic factors; that most
patients with this condition require admission to hospital; and that b
ilateral ECT is the most effective treatment. The answers to the quest
ionnaires established areas where the audience did not modify their re
sponses because they were already well-informed, others where their vi
ews were considerably changed (e.g. ''psychotic'' episodes in those wi
th a borderline personality disorder) and others where they modified t
heir clinical reasoning (e.g. ''it a ''psychotic'' feature is mood-con
gruent then the condition must be an affective disorder'' became ''it
the patient has an affective disorder, the psychotic feature must be m
ood-congruent''). Finally, we make some recommendations for future con
sensus conferences.