In Rebellious Lawyering: One Chicano's Vision of Progressive Law Pract
ice, Gerald Lopez portrays an alternative vision of how lawyers can be
st help poor clients. Using a blend of exposition and storytelling, Lo
pez critiques traditional civil rights and poverty lawyers, and advoca
tes nonhierarchical collaboration between clients and attorneys with a
n eye toward political mobilization rather than litigation. Professor
Southworth, in her review essay Taking the Lawyer Out of Progressive L
awyering, faults Lopez for failing to provide a complete and accurate
picture of both the process and the substance of lawyering for the poo
r. She contends that Lopez's model misses the ways in which lawyers ca
n facilitate clients' assertion of control, and underemphasizes the sk
ills lawyers can and should offer to clients. Southworth describes a b
road range of activities that lawyers are performing for poor clients
today, including counseling and transactional work for community organ
izations and small businesses.