Re. Koeppe et al., ORIENTATIONS OF THE TRYPTOPHAN 9 AND 11 SIDE-CHAINS OF THE GRAMICIDINCHANNEL BASED ON DEUTERIUM NUCLEAR-MAGNETIC-RESONANCE SPECTROSCOPY, Biophysical journal, 66(1), 1994, pp. 14-24
Deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to investig
ate the orientations of the indole rings of Trp(9) and Trp(11) in spec
ific indole-d(5)-labeled samples of gramicidin A incorporated into dim
yristoyl phosphatidylcholine bilayers in the beta(6.3) channel conform
ation. The magnitudes and signs of the deuterium quadrupolar splitting
s were fit to the rings and assigned to specific ring bonds, using a f
ull rotation search of the chi(1) and chi(2) angles of each Trp and a
least-squares method. Unique assignments were obtained. The data and a
ssignments are in close agreement with four sets of (chi(1), chi(2)) a
ngles for each Trp in which the indole N-H is oriented toward the memb
rane's exterior surface. (Four additional sets of (chi 1, chi(2)) angl
es with the N-H's pointing toward the membrane interior are inconsiste
nt with previous observations.) One of the sets of (chi(1), chi(2)) an
gles for each Trp is consistent with the corresponding Trp orientation
found by Arsen'ev et al. (1986. Biol. Membr. 3:1077-1104) for gramici
din in sodium dodecyl sulfate micelles. Together, the H-1 and H-2 nucl
ear magnetic resonance methods suggest that the Trp(9) and Trp(11) sid
e chain orientations could be very similar in dimyristoyl phosphatidyl
choline membranes and in sodium dodecyl sulfate micelles. The data for
Trp(11) could be fit using a static quadrupolar coupling constant of
180 kHz under the assumption that the ring is essentially immobile. By
contrast, Trp(9) could be fit only under the assumption that the quad
rupolar splittings for ring 9 are reduced by approximately 14% due to
motional averaging. Such a difference in motional averaging between ri
ngs 11 and 9 is also consistent with the N-15 data of Hu et al. (1993.
Biochemistry. 32:7035-7047).