Jj. Blanchard et Jm. Neale, THE NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL SIGNATURE OF SCHIZOPHRENIA - GENERALIZED OR DIFFERENTIAL DEFICIT, The American journal of psychiatry, 151(1), 1994, pp. 40-48
Objective: The aim of this study was to provide a comprehensive assess
ment of neuropsychological functioning in schizophrenia so as to evalu
ate hypothesis of lateralized or differential cognitive impairment in
this disorder. Furthermore, the study sought to address the potentiall
y confounding factors of medication side effects and relevant demograp
hic variables such as age, education, gender, and handedness. Method:
The neuropsychological functioning of 28 schizophrenic patients whose
medication had been withdrawn for research purposes and 15 demographic
ally matched normal subjects was evaluated. A comprehensive battery of
tasks was used to determine whether performance patterns of schizophr
enic patients were consistent with models of lateralized or localized
neuropsychological impairment in schizophrenia. To facilitate comparis
on with results of other studies, several analytic strategies were use
d, including comparisons of group performance on individual tests, com
posite function scores, and evaluation of performance based on ''clini
cal'' criteria of impairment. Results: In contrast to the normal subje
cts, the schizophrenic patients displayed impairment across measures o
f motor, sensory, and perceptual functioning, verbal and nonverbal mem
ory, and indexes of frontal lobe functioning. This pattern of generali
zed dysfunction was evident regardless of the method of analysis used
to assess performance. Conclusions: These findings fail to support con
jectures regarding differential neurocognitive deficits in schizophren
ia. However, the psychometric limitations of currently available neuro
psychological measures may obscure the finding of differential impairm
ent and must be considered in interpreting the results of this study a
s well as those of any investigation using such instruments.