Recent work by Angrist and Krueger (1991,1992) utilised an ''experimen
t'' to distinguish an individual's return to schooling where additiona
l schooling is by choice compared to the return when extra schooling i
s compulsory. Here we use a similar ''experiment'' generated by the ra
ising of the school leaving age (ROSLA) from 15 to 16 in the mid-'70s
in England and Wales. Preliminary estimates from the Family Expenditur
e Survey over the period 1978-1986 suggest that for boys affected by R
OSLA the effect of compulsory schooling is significantly less than tha
t for elective schooling. In addition our estimates suggest that the l
oss of experience associated with this imposed extra year of schooling
could well imply a negative net return for boys. However the results
for girls suggest that additional compulsory schooling has the same ef
fect as elective schooling.