Re. Ernst et Kl. Buchan, PALEOMAGNETISM OF THE ABITIBI DYKE SWARM, SOUTHERN SUPERIOR-PROVINCE,AND IMPLICATIONS FOR THE LOGAN LOOP, Canadian journal of earth sciences, 30(9), 1993, pp. 1886-1897
The trace of the Middle Proterozoic Logan Loop of the North American a
pparent polar wander path is controversial. The older 1270 - 1110 Ma l
imb of the loop is poorly constrained, while the depth of the loop, ba
sed on the 1110 - 1080 Ma Keweenawan data of the younger limb, is thou
ght by some to be largely an artifact of reversal asymmetry in the Ear
th's magnetic field. Paleomagnetism of the 1141 Ma Abitibi mafic dyke
swarm is one of the keys to constraining the geometry of the Logan Loo
p. Unfortunately, previous paleomagnetic studies failed to distinguish
dykes of the northeast-trending Middle Proterozoic olivine-bearing Ab
itibi swarm from subparallel Early Proterozoic olivine-free Biscotasin
g (formerly Preissac) dykes, and hence paleomagnetic poles determined
in these studies should no longer be used. In the present study, sampl
ing of eight Abitibi dykes has identified 23 normally magnetized sites
in four dykes and, for the first time, five reversely magnetized site
s in three dykes. One of the normally magnetized sites corresponds to
the locality for which a high-precision U - Pb age was previously repo
rted. A baked contact test establishes that the characteristic remanen
ce of one normally magnetized dyke is primary. In addition, sites alon
g individual dykes exhibit much smaller secular variation than is obse
rved between dykes, indicating that the remanences of the other dykes
are also primary. One of the normally magnetized dykes, the 700 km lon
g Great Abitibi dyke, exhibits two primary directions that correspond
to two geochemically distinct magma pulses. The five normally magnetiz
ed units, which consist of four separate dykes plus the second pulse o
f the Great Abitibi dyke, yield a well-defined mean paleomagnetic pole
at 42.8-degrees-N, 151.5-degrees-W, dm = 16.3-degrees, dp = 12.5-degr
ees. It falls close to the reversely magnetized poles from the Keweena
wan Track and establishes a minimum depth for the Logan Loop of about
40-degrees. The reversed-polarity data from three other dykes are more
scattered and may not average out secular variation. Hence, the prese
nt study is inconclusive, regarding asymmetry of the Earth's magnetic
field at 1141 Ma, even though a mean pole based on combined normal- an
d reversed-polarity dykes is indistinguishable from that based on norm
al-polarity dykes alone.