T. Silva, TOWARD AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE DISTINCT NATURE OF L2 WRITING - THE ESL RESEARCH AND ITS IMPLICATIONS, TESOL quarterly, 27(4), 1993, pp. 657-675
Dealing effectively with L2 writers requires a clear understanding of
the nature of L2 writing. In an attempt to develop such an understandi
ng, 72 reports of empirical research comparing L1 and L2 writing were
examined. The findings of this research indicate a number of salient d
ifferences between Ll and L2 writing with regard to both composing pro
cesses (and subprocesses: planning, transcribing, and reviewing) and f
eatures of written texts (fluency, accuracy, quality, and structure, i
.e., discoursal, morphosyntactic, and lexicosemantic). Implications of
the findings for L2 and L1 writing theory; future comparative writing
research; and the practical concerns of assessment, placement, staffi
ng, and instruction are discussed.