Bj. Zhao et al., SOIL CATION-EXCHANGE CAPACITY MEASUREMENTS USING ULTRAFILTRATION TECHNIQUES - COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT METAL-IONS AS SUBSTITUTES, Communications in soil science and plant analysis, 28(1-2), 1997, pp. 161-171
An attempt was made to introduce a membrane ultrafiltration technique
into the measurement of soil cation exchange capacity (CEC). The CEC d
ata from four soil samples obtained using the simplified method yielde
d identical results to those obtained using conventional methods. The
potential for automation of the method was discussed. Using the copper
(Cu2+) ion as a substitute resulted in higher CEC values than obtaine
d using sodium (Na+) ion as a substitute. The degree of increase is po
sitively correlated to the concentration of organic material present i
n the soil. The difference in stability constants of complexes between
soil organic matter (humic acids and fulvic acids) and metal ions acc
ounted for the differences in the soil CEC values measured at the same
reaction time with different metal ions as substitutes. In fact, the
incompleteness of the substitution reaction was the ultimate reason fo
r the difference in measured CEC values. This result raises the questi
on regarding the reliability of conventional methods for the measureme
nt of soil CEC, especially when applied to soils rich in organic matte
r.