Ema. Smaling et Lo. Fresco, A DECISION-SUPPORT MODEL FOR MONITORING NUTRIENT BALANCES UNDER AGRICULTURAL LAND-USE (NUTMON), Geoderma, 60(1-4), 1993, pp. 235-256
A quantitative model of the balance between inputs and outputs of nitr
ogen, phosphorus and potassium in African land use systems (NUTBAL) wa
s recently developed at two scales: supra-national (38 sub-Saharan Afr
ican countries) and regional (Kisii District, Kenya). Calculating inpu
ts (mineral fertilizer, organic manure, wet and dry deposition, biolog
ical nitrogen fixation, sedimentation) and outputs (removal of above-g
round crop parts, leaching, denitrification, water erosion) led to the
conclusion that there are considerable net fertility losses in each g
rowing period. In this paper, NUTBAL is elaborated into a decision-sup
port model (NUTMON) to monitor the effects of changing land use, and s
uggest interventions that improve the nutrient balance. As input and o
utput determinants cannot all be quantified equally well, the model re
cognizes primary data, estimates, and assumptions. The NUTMON determin
ants are mostly scale-neutral and can therefore be used to monitor nut
rient balances at farm, regional, national and supra-national level. T
his is essential since the hierarchical levels interact. A number of r
ecent interventions at the regional level (Kisii District, Kenya) are
elaborated, including national fertilizer and produce price policies,
fertilizer supply in small packages, zero-grazing, agroforestry, soil
conservation measures, and increasing fertilizer use efficiency. It is
shown that a major nutrient conservation effort in Kisii reduces nutr
ient depletion by approximately 50%, but does not entirely redress the
N and K balance. To achieve the latter without reducing crop producti
on, 75% of the district would have to be converted to a rotation syste
m of maize and green manure cover crops, whereas 25% can remain under
tea. NUTMON has the potential to become a dynamic tool for land use po
licies, geared towards a balanced nutrient status in African land use
systems. It can assist decision makers in determining the effects of c
uffent and alternative land use scenarios, taking account of both the
productivity as well as the long-term sustainability of agro-ecosystem
s.