M. Eneva et al., ARTIFICIAL AND NATURAL CHANGES IN THE RATES OF SEISMIC ACTIVITY - A CASE-STUDY OF THE GARM REGION, TAJIKISTAN (CIS), Geophysical journal international, 116(1), 1994, pp. 157-172
Seismicity rate variations observed in earthquake catalogues can be na
tural, i.e. associated with temporal variations in the seismic process
, or they can be artificial, i.e. related to changes in the networks o
f seismic stations used to create these catalogues. Such artificial ch
anges must be identified and corrected before real variations can be r
eliably examined. This paper demonstrates techniques for modelling of
the observed changes in seismicity rates in order to determine their o
rigin. The main technique used here has been previously applied to a n
umber of catalogues to identify times of rate changes. It can be used
to demonstrate the magnitude dependence of these changes and the exist
ence of two major types of possible artificial rate variations, detect
ion changes and magnitude shifts. In addition, two new techniques are
applied. One of them, the variable window technique, makes use of wind
ows of different sizes to sample the data, thus addressing some of the
shortcomings of the original approach. The other new technique, catal
ogue randomization, helps analyse the cause of some of the rate change
s; it is most helpful in the cases of pure magnitude shifts. The use o
f these techniques is demonstrated examining data from the Garm region
, Tadjikistan (former Soviet Union). The Garm earthquake catalogue inc
ludes more than 85 000 events for the period 1955 January-1989 April a
nd covers an 80 km x 100 km area in the collisional zone between the I
ndian and Eurasian plates. Known changes in the Garm network, recently
documented in detail, were compared with the rate changes identified
with the above techniques. Of the 18 main rate variations identified,
at least two-thirds were found to be artificial. Most of them were rea
dily associated with reported changes in the network, such as closure
and opening of stations, and/or changes in instrumentation. Of the rat
e changes determined to be natural, most prominent were the ones assoc
iated with a possible quiescence preceding a M6.3 event and its afters
hock sequence. Finally, other authors' reports of linear trends and an
nual periodicity in the seismic activity at Garm are critically examin
ed.