Mr. Haynes et al., ROUTES TO CATALYSIS - STRUCTURE OF A CATALYTIC ANTIBODY AND COMPARISON WITH ITS NATURAL COUNTERPART, Science, 263(5147), 1994, pp. 646-652
The three-dimensional structure of a catalytic antibody (1F7) with cho
rismate mutase activity has been determined to 3.0 angstrom resolution
as a complex with a transition state analog. The structural data sugg
est that the antibody stabilizes the same conformationally restricted
pericyclic transition state as occurs in the uncatalyzed reaction. Ove
rall shape and charge complementarity between the combining site and t
he transition state analog dictate preferential binding of the correct
substrate enantiomer in a conformation appropriate for reaction. Comp
arison with the structure of a chorismate mutase enzyme indicates an o
verall similarity between the catalytic mechanism employed by the two
proteins. Differences in the number of specific interactions available
for restricting the rotational degrees of freedom in the transition s
tate, and the lack of multiple electrostatic interactions that might s
tabilize charge separation in this highly polarized metastable species
, are likely to account for the observed 10(4) times lower activity of
the antibody relative to that of the natural enzymes that catalyze th
is reaction. The structure of the 1F7 Fab'-hapten complex provides con
firmation that the properties of an antibody catalyst faithfully refle
ct the design of the transition state analog.