Dg. Musaev et K. Morokuma, AB-INITIO MOLECULAR-ORBITAL STUDY OF ELECTRONIC AND GEOMETRICAL STRUCTURES OF MCH(2)(-2, WHERE M=CO, RH, AND IR() COMPLEX AND ITS REACTIVITY WITH H), Israel Journal of Chemistry, 33(3), 1993, pp. 307-316
By using CASSCF (for optimization of geometries) and MR-SDCI-CASSCF (f
or energies) methods we have studied and compared the mechanism of rea
ction MCH(2)(+) + H-2, as well as the electronic and geometrical struc
ture of the MCH(2)(+) complex, where M = Co, Rh, and Ir. It has been f
ound that the mechanisms of reaction MCH(2)(+) + H-2 --> M(+) + CH4 (1
) for M = Co and Rh are similar and follow the path: MCH(2)(+) + H-2 -
-> (H-2)MCH(2)(+) --> [TS1, H-2-activation] --> MCH(4)(+) --> M(+) + C
H4. The key step is activation of the H-H bond, which has a barrier ab
out twice as high for M = Co as for M = Rh; reaction (1) occurs more e
asily for M = Rh than M = Co. M = Ir completely changes the mechanism
of reaction (1), which now follows the path: IrCH2+((3)A(2)) + H-2 -->
(H-2)IrCH2+((3)A(2)) --> [TS1, H-2-activation] --> (H)(2)IrCH2+((1)A'
) --> [TS2, H-migration] --> HIrCH3+((3)A) --> [TS3, CH4-elimination]
--> IrCH4+((3)A(2)) --> Ir+(F-5, s(1)d(7)) + CH4. The reaction (1) is
exothermic for M = Co and Rh, but endothermic for M = Ir. For M = Co a
nd Rh, the reverse reaction M(+) + CH4 can give only one product MCH(4
)(+) and does not proceed further easily; for M = Co, at elevated temp
erature CoCH4+ may give CoH+ and CoCH3+. However, for M = Ir the rever
se reaction can proceed further to give hydridomethyl HIrCH3+ and bish
ydrido (H)(2)IrCH2+ complexes, as well as IrCH4+.