The outcome of islet isolation is considered uncertain because of the
large variability of islet and insulin yield, but comparison of the is
olated and native islet PoPulation has not been attempted. We therefor
e addressed the efficacy of collagenase digestion, and density gradien
t purification of islets from the splenic dog pancreas (n = 31) by mor
phometry of the islet volume and size distribution, and by extraction
of insulin and amylase, in samples from the pancreas, the digest, and
gradient fractions. In contrast to a approximately 90% recovery of pan
creatic insulin and amylase after digestion, islet yield amounted to 5
0% of the islet content of the pancreas. After density separation, isl
ets were mainly found in the purified fractions, while half of the rec
overed insulin was located in the acinar fraction of the gradients-ind
icating a substantial proportion of islets entrapped in acinar fragmen
ts. The islet and insulin content of the pancreas correlated well with
islet and insulin yield after digestion (r = 0.7, p < .0001). The ins
ulin content of digest suspensions did neither correlate with islet no
r insulin recovery in the purified fraction of the gradients (r = 0.4)
as opposed to the islet content of digest suspensions, which correlat
ed with both (r = 0.7, p < .0001). After density separation near 100%
purity was obtained, and no loss of insulin from isolated islets was d
emonstrated by extraction and microscopy. Size distributions of native
and isolated islets demonstrated no fragmentation. We conclude that t
he variability of isolation outcome may be attributed to a large exten
t to the variability of the native endocrine pancreas. Isolation effic
acy was best documented by morphometry, because insulin extraction did
not discriminate between free and entrapped islets. However, assessme
nt by both morphometry and extraction allowed the quantitation of entr
apped islets, and demonstrated preservation of beta-cell granulation.
Similar studies should facilitate the analysis of other factors affect
ing islet isolation in man.