Secure initial stability is crucial for prostheses designed for biolog
ical ingrowth without it, subsequent tissue ingrowth is impossible. Me
chanical testing was performed in vitro to measure the interface shear
stability of acetabular cup prostheses. Cemented, threaded, finned, a
nd press-fit cups, both with and without supplemental screw fixation,
were tested. A mechanically consistent polyethylene foam was used as a
substrate to obviate the variations inherent in cadaver bones. Ramped
, eccentric rim loads were applied using a servohydraulic materials te
sting system. Reaming, insertion, and loading variables were carefully
controlled. Cups with external threads were significantly more stable
than those fixed by fins or screws. Press-fit cups were significantly
looser than all other tested designs. None of the uncemented prosthes
es approached the initial stability of cups secured with acrylic bone
cement.