I. Sivin et al., HEALTH DURING PROLONGED USE OF LEVONORGESTREL 20 MU-G D AND THE COPPER TCU 380AG INTRAUTERINE CONTRACEPTIVE DEVICES - A MULTICENTER STUDY/, Fertility and sterility, 61(1), 1994, pp. 70-77
Objectives: To measure and compare the incidence of adverse events dur
ing use of two medicated intrauterine devices (IUDs). Design: A multic
enter prospective 7-year randomized study. Setting: Family planning cl
inics, primarily in developing countries. Subjects: Women age 18 to 38
years at admission, desiring contraception and without contraindicati
ons to IUDs. Main Outcome Measures: Incidence of complaints, condition
s, and rates of specific termination for each IUD. Methods: Subjects r
ecorded menstrual events, and clinical staff registered all complaints
and conditions found on examination at four first-year clinic visits
and at semiannual visits thereafter. Difference in rates were analyzed
by chi 2 statistics. Results: Annual pregnancy rates for each IUD ave
raged 0.2/100 women whereas upper genital tract infection occurred at
rates of 0.6 to 0.7 per 100 years of use. The levonorgestrel-releasing
IUD significantly decreased bleeding and spotting days in comparison
with historical data for noncontraceptors and with the copper-medicate
d IUD. Dysmenorrhea, vaginitis, and myoma in women with the levonorges
trel IUD were markedly decreased in comparison with the experience of
copper IUD users. Significantly higher rates of amenorrhea, delayed ov
arian follicular atresia, skin and hair conditions, and headache were
observed with the steroid IUD than with the copper-releasing IUD. Rate
s of reported adverse effects for either IUD were highest in the first
2 years of use and among women under age 25. Conclusions: Long-term u
se of copper or levonorgestrel IUDs is characterized by very low rates
of pregnancy and by a low and declining annual incidence of side effe
cts, including pelvic infection and borderline anemia. The levonorgest
rel-releasing IUD reduced the incidence of bleeding and, in the long t
erm, of myoma and myoma-related surgery in comparison with the copper
T IUD. Both IUDs proved highly acceptable and had few unanticipated si
de effects.