Bf. Malle et J. Knobe, WHICH BEHAVIORS DO PEOPLE EXPLAIN - A BASIC ACTOR-OBSERVER ASYMMETRY, Journal of personality and social psychology, 72(2), 1997, pp. 288-304
Attribution research has focused on how people explain behavior; the p
resent paper examines which behaviors they explain. The authors introd
uce a framework that specifies when people wonder about and explain an
event. Applied to behavior, the framework predicts which behavioral e
vents (intentional vs. unintentional and observable vs. unobservable)
actors and observers tend to explain: (a) Actors wonder more often abo
ut unintentional and unobservable behaviors, whereas observers wonder
more often about intentional and observable behaviors. (b) In private
explanations (directed to oneself), actors explain more unintentional
and unobservable behaviors, whereas observers explain more intentional
and observable behaviors. (c) In communicative explanations (directed
to others), both actors and observers explain more intentional and ob
servable behaviors. These hypotheses are supported in 5 studies using
thought protocols, memory protocols, diaries, conversations, and novel
s.