Te. Malloy et al., INTERPERSONAL PERCEPTION AND METAPERCEPTION IN NONOVERLAPPING SOCIAL-GROUPS, Journal of personality and social psychology, 72(2), 1997, pp. 390-398
Consensus, self-ether agreement, and meta-accuracy were studied within
and across nonoverlapping social groups. Thirty-one target persons we
re judged on the Big Five factors by 9 informants: 3 family members, 3
friends, and 3 coworkers. Although well acquainted within groups, inf
ormants were unacquainted between groups. A social relations analysis
conducted within each social group showed reliable consensus on the Bi
g Five personality factors. A model specified to estimate the consiste
ncy of a target person's effect on perceptions by others across social
groups showed weaker agreement across groups. That is, targets were p
erceived consensually within groups, but these consensual perceptions
differed between groups. The data suggest that personality and identit
y are context specific; however, there was some evidence of agreement
in perceptions across groups.