In the processing of pharmaceutical solids, disruption or activation o
f the crystalline structure often leads to varying degrees of disorder
through the formation of defects and amorphous regions. Since percent
disorder of processed samples must be assessed quantitatively using p
remixed standard samples of highly crystalline and amorphous solids, i
n the past, a number of questions about the validity of such an approa
ch have been raised. Using sucrose as a model solid, a comprehensive a
ssessment of such disorder has been carried out on predetermined mixtu
res of crystalline and amorphous samples, as well as on crystalline sa
mples mechanically milled for various periods of time. Particular emph
asis was placed on determining low levels of disorder in highly crysta
lline samples, since most techniques can detect no less than about 10%
disorder. With predetermined mixtures, measurements of X-ray powder d
iffraction, density and heats of crystallization revealed good lineari
ty with the percent disorder and acceptable detectability down to abou
t 10%, as expected. However, using water vapor sorption measurements u
nder very carefully controlled conditions proved effective in being ab
le to detect disorder as low as 1%. A comparison of these four methods
for estimating the percent disorder of milled samples of sucrose gave
very consistent results, once the underlying factors that make these
techniques sensitive to the concentration of amorphous structure prese
nt were recognized and taken into account.