Pe. Smith et al., U-PB SYSTEMATICS AND ALTERATION TRENDS OF PENNSYLVANIAN-AGED ARAGONITE AND CALCITE, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 58(1), 1994, pp. 313-322
Carbonate allochems from the mid-Pennsylvanian Buckhorn fauna of the B
oggy Formation, Oklahoma, USA, consist of primary aragonite preserved
in nautiloids and of secondary low-Mg calcite present in crinoids and
corals. Unaltered nautiloids contain 11-38 ppb U and 23-422 ppb Pb, an
d have low U-238/Pb-204 (mu) values from 4.1-14.8. They give a U-238-P
b-206 isochron age of 311 +/- 48 Ma (2sigma), which is in agreement wi
th the assigned stratigraphic age (mid-Desmoinsian; approximately 305
Ma) of the Boggy Formation sediments. Their initial lead isotope ratio
s are Pb-206/Pb-204 = 19.11 +/- 0.08, Pb-207/Pb-204 = 15.70 +/- 0.04,
and Pb-208/Pb-204 approximately 38.7, and reflect an upper crustal sou
rce for Pb in mid-Pennsylvanian seawater. These values are similar to
those of coals of this age, The contents of both U and Pb in the Buckh
orn nautiloids are significantly higher than those found in the modem
nautilus Nautilus pompilius. These enrichments are attributed to bitum
en which was added to the carbonates during diagenesis. The diagenetic
transformation of aragonite to low-Mg calcite in the Buckhorn nautilo
ids was apparently associated with a net loss of Pb, thereby increasin
g their mu values. The secondary carbonates of crinoids contain 265-35
2 ppb U, 136-262 ppb Pb, and their mu values range from 68-111; conseq
uently, their present-day uranogenic lead isotopic ratios are higher t
han those of the Buckhorn nautiloids. The U-Pb data for some diageneti
c low-Mg components indicate an age of approximately 280 Ma suggesting
an early timing for the post-depositional alteration process. The app
arent initial lead isotope ratios of crinoids are variable, and some a
re significantly higher than the coexisting aragonite (Pb-206/Pb-204 =
20.50, Pb-207/Pb-204 = 15.73). This very radiogenic signature is simi
lar to those of Mississippi Valley-type ore deposits and both types ma
y share a similar genesis.