M. Dellian et al., HIGH-ENERGY SHOCK-WAVES ENHANCE HYPERTHERMIC RESPONSE OF TUMORS - EFFECTS ON BLOOD-FLOW, ENERGY-METABOLISM, AND TUMOR-GROWTH, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 86(4), 1994, pp. 287-293
Background: The ability to kill cancerous tissue by heating is often l
imited by heat lost to flowing blood. Recent studies demonstrate that
high-energy shock waves (HESWs), when applied to solid tumors, destroy
the tumor microvasculature and rapidly decrease blood flow. We hypoth
esized that impairment of tumor blood flow by HESWs might result in in
creased effectiveness of hyperthermia treatment. Purpose: The purpose
of our work was to determine whether HESWs enhance the response of tum
ors to hyperthermia. Methods: Seventy A-Mel-3 amelanotic hamster melan
omas were exposed to either 700 HESWs (20 kV, 80 nanofarads), local hy
perthermia (43.3-degrees-C for 30 minutes), or a combination of both.
Three, 12, or 24 hours later, tumor blood flow and adenosine triphosph
ate (ATP) concentrations were measured by [4-N-methyl-C-14]iodoantipyr
ine autoradiography and quantative ATP imaging bioluminescence, respec
tively. In separate experiments, the effects of the separate and combi
ned treatments on tumor growth were studied in 52 animals. Results: Co
mbining HESWs and hyperthermia produced a significantly longer and mor
e pronounced reduction of tumor and adjacent tissue perfusion than eit
her HESWs or hyperthermia alone (P<.05). ATP concentrations were marke
dly reduced following HESW treatment alone and following the combined
therapy compared with untreated controls (P<.05). Three hours after co
mbined therapy, ATP concentrations were significantly below values mea
sured after hyperthermia alone (P<.01). Tumor growth was delayed much
more effectively by the combination of HESWs and hyperthermia than by
either treatment alone (P<.001). Fifty-four percent of the animals rec
eiving combined treatment showed complete local tumor cure over 52 day
s of observation, and 46% showed partial remission. Conclusion: The co
mbination of HESWs and hyperthermia might be an effective new way of t
reating cancer, especially in patients who are not candidates for surg
ery. Implications: These results must be viewed cautiously, as the vas
culature of human tumors seems to be less sensitive to hyperthermia th
an has been observed in experimental tumors.