A. Lloyd et al., CYTOKINE PRODUCTION AND FATIGUE IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC FATIGUE SYNDROME AND HEALTHY CONTROL SUBJECTS IN RESPONSE TO EXERCISE, Clinical infectious diseases, 18, 1994, pp. 190000142-190000146
We have studied the relationship between the cytokine production induc
ed in vivo by prolonged isometric exercise and the symptom complex mar
ked by fatigue in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Twelve
male patients and 13 matched male control subjects undertook an isome
tric hand-grip exercise protocol utilizing dynamometers. Subjects unde
rtook 30 minutes of exercise, for which the target force was set at 40
% of the maximal voluntary contraction and the duty cycle was 50%. Pri
or to, during, and for 24 hours following the exercise, blood samples
were collected and assayed for the presence of cytokines, including in
terferon-gamma and interferon-alpha, interleukin-1 beta, and tumor nec
rosis factor-alpha. At those times subjects also completed the Profile
of Mood States (POMS) questionnaire, which served as a measure of cha
nges in subjective fatigue. No significant alteration in the level of
any of the cytokines in the plasma of patients or control subjects was
detected before, during, or after exercise. Surprisingly, the patient
s' levels of fatigue, depression, and confusion, as measured by the PO
MS, decreased in response to the exercise. These data do not confirm t
he presence of an immunologic process correlating with the exacerbatio
n of fatigue after exercise experienced by patients with CFS. Limitati
ons in the study design and in the sensitivity of the cytokine assays
may have affected our results.