The effects of highly and moderately acid soils on total biomass, biom
ass partitioning, fine root characteristics and nutritional status of
beech seedlings (Fagus sylvatica L.) were studied in a growth chamber
experiment. In Haplic Arenosols seedlings grew slowly but equally well
without damage symptoms in a highly acid and a moderately acid soil h
orizon. The moderately acid A(h) + B(w)-horizon of a Eutric Cambisol w
as favourable to seedling growth. The fine root development was reduce
d in the highly acid A + B(w)-horizon of a Dystric Cambisol and in the
A(h) + E-horizon of a Haplic Podzol, the latter of which also caused
increased mortality. Seedling growth in the B2-horizon of the Haplic P
odzol was vigorous, in spite of a higher level of extractable Al and l
ower base saturation as compared with the A(h) + E-horizon. These resu
lts are interpreted in relation to soil acidity, soil Al and nutrition
al status of the seedlings. We conclude that neither Al-toxicity nor n
utrient deficiency cause the damage symptoms observed in the A(h) + E-
horizon of a Haplic Podzol and the fine root reduction in the A + B(w)
-horizon of a Dystric Cambisol. The damage symptoms of the PZh(A) trea
tment seems to be more the result of H-toxicity or H-related factors o
ther than nutrient shortage or Al-toxicity. Other pH-related toxic fac
tors are discussed.