Plant breeders often conduct preliminary tests of genotypes at one or
two primary locations due to limited seed supply and/or limited resour
ces. The location of these tests may be somewhat arbitrary, and in gen
eral, it is not known how performance at these locations relates to pe
rformance in a much broader target environment. The objective of this
study was to develop a method for weighting performance at primary loc
ations, based on the genetic correlations between these locations and
the target environment, that would lead to greater predictive value of
the primary locations. Using data from wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em
. Thell) and soybean (Glycine mar L.) cultivar trials in Kentucky from
1987 to 1991, we developed a selection index based on the genetic cor
relations of cultivar performance in the primary locations, Lexington
(LEX) and Princeton (PR), and the target environment, represented by a
s many as seven locations from the cultivar trials (($) over bar Y). A
s expected from theory, predicted response to index selection exceeded
predicted response to selection at either LEX or PR, and it was super
ior to predicted response of selection based on the unweighted mean of
LEX and PR. In all years, a lower number of statistically significant
wheat genotype rank changes occurred when ranks across the primary lo
cations were based on the index than when ranks were based on the unwe
ighted means. For soybean, this was true in 4 of 5 years. Although the
use of cultivar trial data for parameter estimation violates some of
the usual assumptions of traditional quantitative genetic investigatio
ns, we suggest the potential benefits to breeding programs outweigh th
ese concerns.