Brood raiding, or reciprocal stealing of brood, is common among incipi
ent colonies of the fire ant Solenopsis invicta. Paradoxically, worker
s from a colony that loses its brood during a raid often abandon their
nest and join the winning colony. Queens abandoned by their workers m
ay then migrate from their original nest site and attempt to forcefull
y usurp another incipient colony by displacing that colony's queen or
queens. This study examined factors that influence the success of usur
pation attempts. Queens attempting to usurp a nearby colony after labo
ratory brood raids were successful in less than 30% of trials. Usurpat
ion attempts were more successful if workers familiar to the migrating
queen were present in the nest, as would happen if a queen were to fi
nd the colony to which her workers had moved. Cross-fostering experime
nts showed that this effect was due to familiarity rather than related
ness. Usurpation attempts were less successful if they were delayed by
16 h. The probability of usurpation success was not reduced by doubli
ng the number of defending workers in the invaded colony. However, col
onies founded by three queens were almost always able to resist usurpa
tion attempts. These results support the hypothesis that workers aband
on their natal colony after losing a brood raid to increase the likeli
hood that their queen can usurp the colony to which they migrate. Thes
e results also provide the first evidence that colonies of ants founde
d by several queens are better able to resist usurpation attempts than
colonies founded by a single queen.