Ch. Lusk et al., GROWTH, BIOMASS ALLOCATION AND PLANT NITROGEN CONCENTRATION IN CHILEAN TEMPERATE RAIN-FOREST TREE SEEDLINGS - EFFECTS OF NUTRIENT AVAILABILITY, Oecologia, 109(1), 1997, pp. 49-58
Seedlings of nine southern Chilean trees were grown at three nutrient
supply rates, to examine the roles of growth rate, biomass distributio
n and nutrient use traits in determining species natural distributions
on resource gradients. Relative growth rate (RGR) showed no overall r
elationship with species site requirements, although RGR of fertile-si
te species tended to be more responsive to nutrient supply In the low-
nutrient treatment, infertility-tolerant Fitzroya cupressoides showed
a higher RGR rank than a fertility-demanding species (Laurelia philipp
iana) which outgrew it substantially at the highest supply rate. This
reversal of RGR ranks was associated with divergent nutrient use respo
nses: at high nutrient supply both spp. had similar plant nitrogen con
centrations (PNC), whereas at the low supply rate Fitzroya's productio
n of biomass per unit of assimilated N was twice that of Laurelia's. H
owever, this pattern does not appear to serve as a general explanation
of the respective distributions. of the study species, as RGR ranks o
f most species were unaltered by nutrient supply. At low nutrient avai
lability, no clear differences in shoot:root ratio (SRR) were apparent
between poor-site and fertile-site species. However, at high nutrient
availability, SRR was markedly higher in the latter, resulting from d
ifferences in biomass allocation to stems (not leaves). Leaf area rati
os (LAR) were higher in fertile-site species than in those tolerant of
low fertility, because of differences in specific leaf area rather th
an leaf weight ratio. Very high LAR at high nutrient supply was charac
teristic of most shade-tolerant angiosperms, but not of shade-tolerant
conifers. Although PNC showed no overall differences between poor- an
d fertile-site species, sensitivity of PNC to external supply rate was
greatest in two infertility-tolerant conifers. In contrast, the angio
sperm Weinmannia trichosperma, although tolerant of low fertility, res
ponded to increased nutrient supply with greatly increased RGR and lit
tle change in PNC. Results show little trait convergence between conif
ers and angiosperms in adaptation both to shade and to infertile soils
; i.e. fitness of different taxa in a given environment may hinge on d
ifferent trait combinations.