Dp. West et Dr. Lux, DATING MYLONITIC DEFORMATION BY THE AR-40-AR-39 METHOD - AN EXAMPLE FROM THE NORUMBEGA FAULT ZONE, MAINE, Earth and planetary science letters, 120(3-4), 1993, pp. 221-237
Strongly mylonitic rocks associated with the regionally extensive Noru
mbega fault zone in south-central Maine provide an excellent opportuni
ty for testing the effects of mylonitization on argon isotopic systems
in muscovite. Ar-40/Ar-39 muscovite age spectra from samples outside
the zone of mylonitization are relatively undisturbed and have well de
fined Early Carboniferous plateau ages. In contrast to these nonmyloni
tized samples, all age spectra for muscovite from the mylonites are hi
ghly discordant. They are characterized by young ages at low extractio
n temperatures, which systematically increase to ages that equal the p
lateau ages for muscovite collected outside the mylonite zone. Detaile
d petrographic observations suggest that these systematic discordances
reflect a mixing of argon components from older, relict, muscovite po
rphyroclasts and fine-grained white mica aggregates that recrystallize
d during mylonitic deformation. Total gas ages of five different grain
size fractions separated from the same mylonite sample become progres
sively younger with decreasing grain size; indicating a larger compone
nt of the recrystallized grains in the finer grain size fractions. Alt
hough the three finest grain size fractions give different total gas a
ges and do not overlap in age for most of their release spectra, their
initial increments do coincide, at approximately 290 Ma, This indicat
es a minimal older age contribution from the relict porphyroclasts in
the initial increments and suggests the 290 Ma age provides a good est
imate for the time of mineral growth associated with mylonitic deforma
tion. These data, combined with kinematic analysis, reveal that the se
gment of the Norumbega fault zone studied, the Sandhill Corner fault,
is a Late Carboniferous-Early Permian dextral strike-slip fault. A lac
k of significant offset in regional Early Carboniferous mineral age pa
tterns across the fault suggests that displacement was probably less t
han 30 km. This study demonstrates that Ar-40/Ar-39 dating methods can
be used to date deformational events effectively, as long as several
important criteria are met. First and foremost, samples must be well c
haracterized prior to analysis. Dynamic recrystallization must have oc
curred at or below the closure temperature of the mineral to be analyz
ed. Regional cooling patterns must also be established through detaile
d thermochronology so that mineral ages and age spectra from the defor
med rocks can be compared to regional cooling ages of the same mineral
. Finally, the effects of excess argon must be negligible.