Recent accretion was measured by the feldspar marker horizon method in
two gravity-drained, managed, marsh impoundments and unmanaged refere
nce marshes located on the rapidly subsiding coast of Louisiana. Water
level management was designed to limit hydrologic exchange to the man
aged marsh by regulating the direction and rate of water flows. During
a drawdown-flooding water management cycle, the unmanaged reference m
arshes had significantly higher vertical accretion rates, higher soil
bulk density and soil mineral matter content, lower soil organic matte
r content, and higher rates of organic matter accumulation than the ma
naged marsh. The rate of mineral matter accumulation was higher in bot
h reference marshes, but was significantly higher in only one. Spatial
variability in accumulation rates was low when analyzed in one manage
d marsh site, suggesting a primarily autochthonous source of matter. I
n contrast, the associated reference marsh apparently received allocht
honous material that settled out in a distinct spatial pattern as wate
r velocity decreased. The impoundment marshes experienced an accretion
deficit of one full order of magnitude (0.1 vs. 1.0 cm/yr) based on c
omparison of accretion and sea level rise data, while the unmanaged re
ference marshes experienced a five-fold smaller deficit or no deficit.
These data suggest that the gravity-drained impoundments likely have
a shorter life expectancy than the reference marshes in the rapidly su
bsiding Louisiana coast.