Dw. Johnson et al., SIMULATED EFFECTS OF ATMOSPHERIC SULFUR DEPOSITION ON NUTRIENT CYCLING IN A MIXED DECIDUOUS FOREST, Biogeochemistry, 23(3), 1993, pp. 169-196
The effects of three S deposition scenarios - 50% reduction, no change
, and 100% increase - on the cycles of N, P, S, K, Ca, and Mg in a mix
ed deciduous forest at Coweeta, North Carolina, were simulated using t
he Nutrient Cycling model (NuCM). The purpose of this exercise was to
compare NuCM's output to observed soil and streamwater chemical change
s and to explore NuCM's response to varying S deposition scenarios. Ec
osystem S content and SO42- leaching were controlled almost entirely b
y soil SO42- adsorption in the simulations, which was in turn governed
by the nature of the Langmuir isotherm set in the model. Both the sim
ulations and the 20-year trends in streamwater SO42- concentration sug
gest that the ecosystem is slowly becoming S saturated. The streamwate
r data suggest S saturation is occurring at a slower rate than indicat
ed by the simulations, perhaps because of underestimation of organic S
retention in the model. Both the simulations and geld data indicated
substantial declines in exchangeable bases in A and BA soil horizons,
primarily due to vegetation uptake. The correspondence of model output
with field data in this case was a result of after-the-fact calibrati
on (i.e. setting weathering rates to very low values) rather than pred
iction, however. Model output suggests that soil exchangeable cation p
ools change rapidly, undergoing annual cycles and multi-decade fluctua
tions. Varying S deposition had very little effect upon simulated vege
tation growth, nutrient uptake, or N cycling. Varying S deposition str
ongly affected simulated Ca2+, Mg2+, K+, and P leaching but caused lit
tle change in soil exchangeable pools of Ca2+ K+, or P because soil ex
changeable pools were large relative to fluxes. Soil exchangeable Mg2 pools were reduced by high rates of S deposition but remained well ab
ove levels sufficient for tree growth. Although the total soil pools o
f exchangeable Ca2+ and K+ were only slightly affected by S deposition
, there was a redistribution of Ca2+ and K+ from upper to lower horizo
ns with increasing S deposition, causing increased base saturation in
the deepest (BC) horizon. The 100% increased S deposition scenario cau
sed increasing peaks in simulated Al3+ concentrations in A horizons af
ter 25 years as a result of large seasonal pulses of SO42- and lowered
base saturation. Simulated soil solution Al3+ concentrations remained
well below toxicity thresholds for selected tree species at the site.