Rt. Merrill et Pl. Mcfadden, GEOMAGNETIC-FIELD STABILITY - REVERSAL EVENTS AND EXCURSIONS, Earth and planetary science letters, 121(1-2), 1994, pp. 57-69
It has been suggested that there are several reverse subchrons in the
Brunhes, and this suggestion is gaining some acceptance. However, such
a suggestion has fundamental implications for the reversal process, b
ecause it implies that the reverse polarity state has been substantial
ly less stable than the normal polarity state during the Brunhes Chron
. Analysis of the latest polarity reversal timescale confirms that the
re is no reason to reject the hypothesis of a common stability for the
two polarity states. The Cretaceous Superchron appears to be a time w
hen the reversal rate slowed to the point where the reversal process a
ctually halted, so does not indicate any difference in the stability o
f the two polarity states. After examining the data we found no convin
cing evidence for even a single reversal event during the Brunhes, and
we conclude that the only reversal excursions that are sufficiently w
ell documented for the Brunhes are the Laschamp and the Blake, Further
, we note that the question of whether of large excursions represent a
borted reversals is unresolved, so excursion data should not at this s
tage be grouped with transition polarity data. Finally, we note that,
most of the time, the nearly axially symmetric normal and reverse pola
rity states appear to be remarkably stable.