Modern views on the representation of function in the cortex make it d
ifficult to maintain the notion that specific subtypes of aphasia are
associated with specific centres within the language area. We have con
ducted a retrospective study on 221 aphasic patients with one contiguo
us vascular lesion in the territory of the middle cerebral artery. The
localization of CT lesions was established within a standardized grid
model. Aphasiological data were based on one or more examinations wit
h the Aachen Aphasia Test. Both sets of data were processed in a data-
and methodbase system. No unequivocal association between type of aph
asia and localization of lesion was found. In a smaller study, partici
pation of basal ganglia and in particular of the head of the caudate n
ucleus in lesions producing aphasia was not confirmed. Concepts of the
localization of a lesion in aphasia must account for changes in patte
rns of aphasic symptoms in the presence of a stable lesion and for the
impact of the neurological condition that has produced the lesion.