THE EFFECT OF HOUSING SYSTEM ON APPARENT DIGESTIBILITY IN PIGS, USINGTHE CLASSICAL AND MARKER (CHROMIC OXIDE, ACID-INSOLUBLE ASH) TECHNIQUES, IN RELATION TO DIETARY-COMPOSITION
Gcm. Bakker et Aw. Jongbloed, THE EFFECT OF HOUSING SYSTEM ON APPARENT DIGESTIBILITY IN PIGS, USINGTHE CLASSICAL AND MARKER (CHROMIC OXIDE, ACID-INSOLUBLE ASH) TECHNIQUES, IN RELATION TO DIETARY-COMPOSITION, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 64(1), 1994, pp. 107-115
The present study examined differences in faecal digestibilities of or
ganic matter (dOM) and crude protein (dXP), between growing pigs house
d either in pens as groups or individually in metabolism cages. In add
ition, a study was made of the influence of dietary composition on the
se observed differences. Four experimental diets were composed by iso-
energetic exchange of maize starch in the control diet with purified c
ellulose (260 g kg(-1)), toasted soyabean hulls (280 g kg(-1)) or rend
erers fat (67 g kg(-1)), respectively. Both in pens and in metabolism
cages, dOM and dXP were measured, using both chromic oxide (Cr2O3) and
acid-insoluble ash (AIA) as markers. In metabolism cages, the results
of the marker method were compared to those of the classical method,
where dOM and dXP were measured by collecting faeces quantitatively. R
ecoveries of both markers were measured, after a period of 10 and 3 da
ys. With Cr2O2 as marker, pen-housing resulted in a dOM which was on a
verage 2.5 (1.7-4.5) units lower and a dXP averaging 4.5 (3.0-5.8) uni
ts lower than measured in the metabolism cages (P < 0.001). No signifi
cant interactions were demonstrated between housing system and dietary
composition. In contrast, with AIA as marker significantly higher dig
estibility values were observed for pigs in pens, when fed the cellulo
se diet. With this diet, the dOM was on average 14.7 units higher and
the dXP was on average 10.9 units higher for the penned pigs. For the
pigs fed one of the other three diets, the dOM was on average 1.5 (0.1
-2.7) units lower and the dXP was on average 3.7(1.9-5.7)units lower.
Thus, with AIA as a marker, the effect of housing system on digestibil
ity interacted with the type of diet (P < 0.05 on dOM and P < 0.01 on
dXP). Comparison between the marker method with the classical method,
showed that Cr2O3 provided similar results. In contrast, AIA displayed
significantly higher dOM and dXP, except with the cellulose diet. Thi
s could be explained by differences in the recoveries of both markers.
For Cr2O3 this was close to 100% and for AIA it varied from 97% on th
e cellulose diet to 183% on the control diet. The analytical procedure
for AIA requires more research. Shortening the measuring period from
10 to 3 days did not prove to be significant, but increased the standa
rd deviations. It was concluded that for practical application, faecal
digestibilities should be measured with penned pigs. According to the
findings, under such conditions Cr2O3 is a good marker. AIA was found
to be unsuitable.