Deep tillage is often prescribed to alleviate subsoil compaction, but
how long do the benefits last? Subsoilers from Deere, DMI, Kewanee, Ty
e, and Yetter were operated at a 280-mm depth on a compacted 25-ha fie
ld in autumn 1990. The different subsoiler designs were evaluated by d
raft, crop residue cover, soil physical properties and yield measureme
nts over the subsequent two growing seasons. Air porosity and cone pen
etrometer measurements showed continuing benefits, from all subsoil op
erations, two years after tillage in areas not trafficked. However, tw
o passes of a tractor recompacted the soil. Controlled traffic is, the
refore, considered essential to obtain long-term benefits from subsoil
ing. Compared to check strips, soybean yield increases for the five su
bsoilers ranged from 3.0 to 6.9% in 1998 and corn yield increases rang
ed from 1.5 to 3.0% in 1992. Economically, the first year yields paid
for the subsoiling, second year increases were profit.