Re. Stoffregen et al., EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES OF ALUNITE .2. RATES OF ALUNITE-WATER ALKALI ANDISOTOPE-EXCHANGE, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 58(2), 1994, pp. 917-929
Rates of alkali exchange between alunite and water have been measured
in hydrothermal experiments of 1 hour to 259 days duration at 150 to 4
00 degrees C. Examination of run products by scanning electron microsc
ope indicates that the reaction takes place by dissolution-reprecipita
tion. This exchange is modeled with an empirical rate equation which a
ssumes a linear decrease in mineral surface area with percent exchange
(f) and a linear dependence of the rate on the square root of the aff
inity for the alkali exchange reaction. This equation provides a good
fit of the experimental data for f = 17% to 90% and yields log rate co
nstants which range from -6.25 moles alkali m(-2)s(-1) at 400 degrees
C to -11.7 moles alkali m(-2)s(-1) at 200 degrees C. The variation in
these rates with temperature is given by the equation log k = -8.17(1
000/T(K)) + 5.54 (r(2) = 0.987) which yields an activation energy of 3
7.4 +/- 1.5 kcal/mol. For comparison, data from O'NEIL and TAYLOR(1967
) and MERIGOUX (1968) modeled with a pseudo-second-order rate expressi
on give an activation energy of 36.1 +/- 2.9 kcal/mol for alkali-felds
par water Na-K exchange. In the absence of coupled alkali exchange, ox
ygen isotope exchange between alunite and water also occurs by dissolu
tion-reprecipitation but rates are one to three orders of magnitude lo
wer than those for alkali exchange. In fine-grained alunites, signific
ant D-H exchange occurs by hydrogen diffusion at temperatures as low a
s 100 degrees C. Computed hydrogen diffusion coefficients range from -
15.7 to -17.3 cm(2)s(-1) and suggest that the activation energy for hy
drogen diffusion may be as low as 6 kcal/mol. These experiments indica
te that rates of alkali exchange in the relatively coarse-grained alun
ites typical of hydrothermal ore deposits are insignificant, and suppo
rt the reliability of K-Ar age data from such samples. However, the fi
ne-grained alunites typical of low temperature settings may be suscept
ible to limited alkali exchange at surficial conditions which could ca
use alteration of their radiometric ages. Furthermore, the rapid rate
of hydrogen diffusion observed at 100-150 degrees C suggests that fine
-grained alunites are susceptible to rapid D-H re-equilibration even a
t surficial conditions.