O. Carney et al., A PROSPECTIVE-STUDY OF THE PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT ON PATIENTS WITH A 1ST EPISODE OF GENITAL HERPES, Genitourinary medicine, 70(1), 1994, pp. 40-45
Objectives-To assess the psychological impact of first episode of geni
tal herpes, and to determine whether this changes over time. Setting a
nd subjects-The Departments of Genitourinary Medicine (GUM), and Derma
tology, Middlesex Hospital London. The study group consisted of patien
ts attending the department of GUM with a clinically proven first epis
ode of genital herpes. Two control groups were recruited; firstly pati
ents without herpes attending the GUM Department and secondly patients
attending the Dermatology Department out patients with chronic dermat
oses. Methods-Patients and controls completed an 87 item, self-adminis
tered psychological questionnaire at 3 monthly intervals for a year. T
he questionnaire consisted of the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ);
the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Questionnaire (HADQ); Illness Atti
tude Scales Illness Concern. Patients were also asked questions about
their sexual behaviour. Results-Ninety one patients (68 women, 23 men)
with genital herpes, 61 GUM controls (42 women, 19 men) and 56 dermat
ology controls (36 women, 20 men) participated. There were no statisti
cally significant demographic differences between patients and control
s. At first visit the proportion of patients classified as ''cases'')
by the GHQ (GHQ cases) were similar for primary herpes patients 62% (5
6/91) and Dermatology controls 52% (29/56) while a significantly small
er proportion of GUM controls 34% (21/61) were classified as GHQ cases
. The primary herpes group were significantly more concerned about the
ir illness than either the GUM controls or the Dermatology controls (p
< 0.002). The proportion of primary herpes patients classified as ''c
ases'' by the GHQ reduced significantly over the initial three month p
eriod with 67% of patients classified as ''cases'' at their first visi
t becoming ''noncases'' after three months (p < 0.0001). Also 50% of t
hose classified as ''cases'' at first visit by the HADQ became ''nonca
ses'' after the initial three months (p = 0.007). The illness concern
scores also decreased significantly from visit one to visit two (means
14.7 vs. 12.3; p < 0.0001). Conclusion-The diagnosis of a first episo
de of genital herpes has a profound emotional effect on patients. If t
hey do not have recurrent episodes, their emotional state improves. Fo
r those who do have recurrences, the level of anxiety and concern rema
ins as high as at the time of their first diagnosis. Clinicians must b
e sensitive to the emotional impact such a diagnosis may bring.