Dc. Wilbur et al., THINPREP(TM) PROCESSOR - CLINICAL-TRIALS DEMONSTRATE AN INCREASED DETECTION RATE OF ABNORMAL CERVICAL CYTOLOGIC SPECIMENS, American journal of clinical pathology, 101(2), 1994, pp. 209-214
The authors compared the accuracy of conventionally prepared smears an
d smears prepared by an automated, fluid-based, thin-layer processing
device in the detection of cytologic abnormalities. A total of 3218 pa
tients from five centers took part in this study, in,which a single ce
rvical sample was split into a matched pair. The conventional smear wa
s made in the routine fashion; the remainder of the cells on the sampl
ing device were rinsed into a transport-fixation fluid. A slide was th
en prepared from the solution using the thin-layer processor. Diagnost
ic findings identified on the two preparations were compared in a blin
ded fashion, and a discrepancy resolution procedure was used to elimin
ate screening differences. Overall, there was a high correlation in th
e diagnoses of the two methods. For low-grade or more severe disease,
the thin-layer method resulted in a 13% increase in tile rate of detec
tion, as compared with the conventional Papanicolaou smear technique.