Re. Gur et al., CLINICAL SUBTYPES OF SCHIZOPHRENIA - DIFFERENCES IN BRAIN AND CSF VOLUME, The American journal of psychiatry, 151(3), 1994, pp. 343-350
Objective: Investigations of the relation of clinical features of schi
zophrenia to neuroanatomic measures have Produced inconclusive results
. The Purpose of this study was to examine measures of whole-brain vol
ume in men and women and relate them to clinical subtypes of schizophr
enia. Method: Magnetic resonance imaging measures of cranial, brain, a
nd ventricular and sulcal CSF volume were examined in 81 patients with
schizophrenia (50 men and 31 women), divided into subgroups based on
their symptom profiles, and 81 demographically matched healthy compari
son subjects. Results: The men had higher cranial and brain volumes th
an the women. The patients had smaller cranial and brain volumes than
the comparison subjects; they also had higher ventricular CSF volumes
and thus higher ventricle-brain ratios (VBRs). Ratio elevations were l
arger for the female than for the male schizophrenic Patients. The pat
ients with predominantly negative symptoms of schizophrenia had higher
VBRs and sulcal CSF-brain ratios than the comparison subjects, althou
gh the component volumes did not differ. The patients with predominant
ly Schneiderian symptoms had higher VBRs than the comparison subjects
but showed reduced cranial and brain volumes. The paranoid patients ha
d normal VBRs, reduced sulcal CSF-brain ratios, and lower cranial and
sulcal CSF volumes. Conclusions: The results suggest two patterns of n
euroanatomic whole-brain abnormalities that differ in severity accordi
ng to the relative prominence of negative, Schneiderian, and paranoid
symptoms. These patterns may reflect differential involvement of dysge
nic and atrophic pathophysiological processes. Sex moderates abnormali
ties in the neuroanatomic features of schizophrenia.