Ka. Holmes et Dm. Benson, EVALUATION OF PHYTOPHTHORA-PARASITICA VAR NICOTIANAE FOR BIOCONTROL OF PHYTOPHTHORA-PARASITICA ON CATHARANTHUS-ROSEUS, Plant disease, 78(2), 1994, pp. 193-199
Isolates of Phytophthora parasitica var. nicotianae were selected for
biocontrol of Phytophthora parasitica, which causes preemergence dampi
ng-off of Catharanthus roseus. Isolates of P. p. nicotianae pathogenic
to tobacco were weakly pathogenic on C. roseus and variable in their
biocontrol of damping-off. Rice grain cultures of P. parasitica (14 21
days old) at 0.05 g per 25.4 cm2 plug tray were optimal for screening
potential biocontrol isolate, in the greenhouse, After screening 41 i
solates in preliminary experiments, 11 isolates were tested in three r
epeated experiments. Three isolates of P. p. nicotianae (402, 602, and
723) that represented the range of effective control of P. parasitica
were chosen for further study. The isolates selected as potential bio
control agents, however, stunted (P = 0.05) main-root extension in C.
roseus. Above-ground growth of C. roseus also was stunted initially by
P. p. nicotianae, as first and second leaves were shorter (P = 0.05)
on plants grown with each isolate compared to leaves of plants in the
uninfested control. Flowering was not affected. P. p. nicotianae was r
ecovered from roots, crowns, and stems of C. roseus seedlings, but not
to the same extent as was P. parasitica, Severity of preemergence dam
ping-off caused by isolates of P. p. nicotianae was related directly t
o the amount of plant tissue colonized by each isolate. Isolate 723 ca
used the least amount of stunting, colonized the least amount of host
tissue, and was the least pathogenic on C. roseus while giving 52% con
trol of isolate 336 of P. parasitica. In addition, isolate 723 was eff
ective (range 13-73%) in protecting C. roseus from several additional
isolates of P. parasitica. Metalaxyl-insensitive isolates of P. parasi
tica were used in population studies with isolate 723 in peat-vermicul
ite medium seeded to C roseus. Incorporation of metalaxyl into one-hal
f of the assay plates permitted enumeration of both antagonist and pat
hogen in the growth medium. Populations of P. parasitica were lowered
when P. p. nicotianae was present. Apparently, one possible mechanism
of biocontrol is direct suppression of the pathogen population through
competition for nutrients. However, use of P. p. nicotianae for bioco
ntrol of preemergence damping-off of C. roseus caused by P. parasitica
does not seem promising unless more effective nonpathogenic isolates
can be found.