The 5-endo cyclization of the 2-formylbenzoyl radical (reaction 2) is
shown to be a highly favored process relative to the alternative, 4-ex
o-trig ring closure. This evidence comes from product studies, includi
ng ESR and laser flash photolysis studies of transient radical interme
diates, from a nitroxide trapping measurement of the rate constant for
cyclization of the 2-formylbenzoyl radical, viz., k(2) = 2 x 10(8) s(
-1) at 45 degrees C, and from the estimated favorable enthalpic change
for 5-endo cyclization vs 4-exo-trig cyclization. It is suggested tha
t rotation of the formyl group in the initially formed conformer of th
e 2-formylbenzoyl radical may be the rate limiting step in this cycliz
ation.