R. Hardoff et al., THE YIELD OF BONE-SCINTIGRAPHY IN CANCER AND NONCANCER PATIENTS - ITSASSOCIATION WITH INDICATION AND CLARITY OP THE REFERRAL QUESTION, Israel journal of medical sciences, 30(2), 1994, pp. 146-152
The yield of bone scintigraphy was assessed in a general hospital. A r
andom 1:2 sample of the bone studies performed within a year was evalu
ated. The referral forms were judged to show absent, ambiguous or clea
r diagnostic questions. The indications for which the study was ordere
d were matched with the scintigraphic diagnosis, and yield was defined
as the proportion of studies with relevant findings on scintigraphy.
The overall yield was 23.5%. In cancer patients the yield was 27.2% an
d in repeat studies 40.2%. In non-cancer patients the yield was 19.8%
and when scintigraphy was perfomed for the evaluation of specific dise
ase entities it was 35.7%. Relatively low-yield indications in non-can
cer patients were suspected metastases 11.1%, and evaluation of X-ray
abnormalities 11.5%. An association between the clarity of the diagnos
tic question and the scintigraphic yield was detected in non-cancer pa
tients. When a diagnostic question was absent the yield was 12%, ambig
uous 19%, and when it was clear 26%. This correlation is probably attr
ibuted to better understanding of this common procedure, and better de
finition of the diagnostic question in patients with diverse clinical
conditions as compared to cancer patients in whom the question always
relates to the presence of bone metastases.