As lung transplantation has become more successful, the selection crit
eria have broadened; however, some relative contraindications to lung
transplantation are controversial. Some programs consider mechanical v
entilation to be a major contraindication to lung transplantation beca
use airway colonization with bacteria may lead to nosocomial infection
and respiratory muscle deconditioning may necessitate prolonged posto
perative ventilatory support. We report our experience of seven double
lung transplant procedures on six patients requiring mechanical venti
lation. Five patients with cystic fibrosis required preoperative mecha
nical ventilation for 7 to 19 days (mean, 10.7 days). One patient with
acute lung injury required 115 days of preoperative mechanical ventil
atory support. Only the latter patient required prolonged (27 days) po
stoperative mechanical ventilation because of respiratory muscle weakn
ess; the others were extubated in 1 to 19 days (mean, 7.8 days). No ea
rly complications related to bacterial infection were seen. Two patien
ts required temporary hemodialysis for transient kidney failure. Three
patients had postoperative neurologic residua; one patient had a tran
sient hemiparesis, and seizures developed in two patients. One patient
died 3 months after transplantation from severe central nervous syste
m complications with no evidence of pulmonary problems; and two patien
ts died 17 months after transplantation, one of them receiving a secon
d double lung transplant for obliterative bronchiolitis. Except for th
e patient who required prolonged preoperative ventilatory support, mec
hanical ventilation did not appear to play a role in the outcome of th
ese patients. The posttransplantation hospital stay and hospital charg
es for patients requiring pretransplantation ventilatory support were
not significantly different from those for other lung transplant recip
ients. Lung transplantation for patients requiring mechanical ventilat
ion is technically feasible, and the previously stated reasons for wit
hholding transplantation for these patients do not appear to be concer
ns for the patient who requires mechanical ventilation for a short per
iod (less than 2 weeks). However, the growing number of lung transplan
t candidates and the limited supply of donor organs have substantially
increased the average waiting time for transplants and mitigate again
st the routine use of mechanical ventilation in lung transplant candid
ates. Therefore mechanical ventilation for lung transplant candidates
is recommended only for patients with acutely reversible deterioration
or with sufficiently accrued seniority on the waiting list to make ea
rly transplantation likely.